Is it possible to live without borrowing money? In Hinduism Brahmins were considered superior , because they were religious guides or Gurus. I dont' think that white people think that they are superior over all other races. Why do most white people think they are the superior race? The problem is Brahmins think they are the superior, only forward caste community who are above all others. Facts about Brahmins. Right from my young age I am seeing a lot of Brahmin friends - they are always selfish! The six proper activities, ranked from the highest to the lowest, are teaching, studying the Vedas, offering ritual sacrifices, officiating at rituals for others, giving gifts, and accepting gifts. Update: To Mr. Jagan, It is Brahmins like you, who are responsible for all the in equalities in the society. For there are no such thing as Tamil Brahmin fitting the description. There are … They have insecurities, a desperate need to feel important, respected and special, because they have no redeeming qualities about themselves. I posted this obnoxious comment from a third rate “brahmin” (some of these people are truly despicable) to keep on record that there are good reasons why many “brahmins” are deeply hated in India. They have secured the loyalty of most Dalits thru moral fictions because the Brahmins are more sophisticated in this domain than the vaisyas. Available data from other leading scientific and technical institutions such as IITs also show the absence of Dalits and OBC scientists. Biblical times maybe. Jews think that they're special and so above anyone else really, even if they won't admit it, and they hate it when Jews get with gentiles, some Jews even go as far as to disown their own kids if they marry gentiles. <> About the author, <> Hinduism – Wikipedia Get ancient Hinduism facts here. Even brahmins fitting into Vedic brahminism (purohits called Vadhyars/ Shashtrigalin Tamil) who conduct rituals like marriages, death ceremonies, Shraddda Karma etc as per vedic practices are extremely money-minded and demand their cut but not necessarily proportionately knowledgeable in mantras and rites. Personally, I don't think this at all. Tamil Brahmins are Tamil-speaking Brahmins, primarily living in Tamil Nadu, although a few of them have settled in other states like, Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Karnataka. What they can or can’t do is then … <> All about Hinduism (Sivananda) I have committed wrongs and caused suffering to many people in the past. 2) Whenever a brahmin guy/girl comes to friends (belonging to other caste / religion) house, they will decline to have anything to eat? 2) Samithadanam (offerings to fire) recommended daily once, by unmarried Brahmacharis), 3) Aboupasanam (offerings to fire — recommended daily twice, by married Adults and unmarried Brahmacharis), 4) Brahma Yagnyam (recommended to perform daily, once, after Madhyaniga Sandhya). Ashley, Ashley, Ashley, why do you think Americans feel they are Superior to GB? Kings prospered through their association with Brahmins and they naturally showed lots of respect to Brahmins. We don’t, we’re actually quite humble and don’t consider ourselves superior to ANYONE, including minorities, “immigrants”, (aren’t we all?) They holocaust was the Germans and really many germans were jewish so it was really a group of people who with in germany the Nazis that were responsible. Not because they think they are superior, but because some things just need to get done, so if you won't do it someone will. The Japanese believe they're the superior race and thus must save/colonize the world . BRAHMINS... are the worst human creatures..they created differences between people by forming caste..and keeping themselves top in society... they are so cheap..narrow minded people.  They can be broadly divided into three religious groups, Gurukkals who follow Saivism, Iyers who follow the Srauta and Smartha tradition and Iyengars who follow Sri Vaishnavism. And Brahmins too exist as a caste only, carrying a false sense of superiority, not as per the original definition and exalted role of Brahmins outlined in varnashrama dharma. <> Spiritual stories One who eats his food by begging, or by means of, one who lives the life of a teacher to teach Vedic knowledge (or arts, archery etc) and lives by, One who leads a life of extreme simplicity (bordering on poverty) as a dharma, one who does not work and earn his livelihood by any other means, one who abhors possessing of material wealth, accumulating and hoarding. I think even God will not forgive for the evil acts that I have done. one who does nitya karma (daily rituals) without fail. Those who do the poojas, prayers and rituals were expected to live a pure life, be very dedicated, be free from lust and greed, lead an extremely simple life (funded purely by donations/ gifts/ grants from Kings or the dakshina —voluntary offering paid by the ritual seekers). People Caucasian is a race. Most of the brahmins of today are brahmana-kshatryas (rulers and buracrats) , Brahmana-Vysyas (businessmen, company executives, traders) or Brahmana-Sudras (workers and skilled labor force – including IT Engineers!). Brahmin only occupies five perfect of all Indian people based on the report in 2005-2007. Why were Brahmins treated superior in ancient India? Is 'Brahmin pride' really justified? LOL Let's … Why do Republicans think they are superior to Democrats? Brahmins did not give us the vedas, or Gayathri Mantra. But every educated brahmin is very much in the rat race of money-making; it has almost come to a stage in Tamil Nadu that if a brahmin boy does not earn in dollars, he is not considered as Brahmin! 5) Pithru Tharpanam (offerings to deceased parents — specific dates in a month, Lunar cycle dependent, to be performed ONLY by those Male members whose father has passed away). These were indeed the essential qualifications for people who were to be fit enough for conducting rituals and also to memorize Vedas and repeat them verbatim, because Vedas were transmitted from generation to generation only through word by mouth. They are considered religiously superior, and are the highest caste in India. Wir und unsere Partner nutzen Cookies und ähnliche Technik, um Daten auf Ihrem Gerät zu speichern und/oder darauf zuzugreifen, für folgende Zwecke: um personalisierte Werbung und Inhalte zu zeigen, zur Messung von Anzeigen und Inhalten, um mehr über die Zielgruppe zu erfahren sowie für die Entwicklung von Produkten. He is an avid reader and a writer. The source of knowledge of all rituals and mantras is Vedas, particularly Yajur Veda for rituals. The caste system is no longer legal in India and yet Brahmin Hindu men continue to act as if they are superior to all other human beings, especially people of Dalit and non-Indian heritage. 2 years ago. Naturally, the tradition … I can think of two reasons why most of the brahmins are fair. 12 COMMENTS. They are totally unfit and incompetent without their caste identity. Your view if prejudiced. I, at no point wish to remotely say that scavanging, or any allied works are inferior, but they are highly skilled jobs which even the most learned people cannot handle. etc. is never offensive, always following ahimsa, never retaliating, never killing, always forbearing, sacrificing. etc. <> Hinduism – Britannica.com, <> Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa When one has the ability to do something in a way that others can’t, it can cause them to believe they are superior. I must agree. Why Brahmin's are like this? Salam Muslim men do think that they are superior to women,but based on the Qur'an we Muslim men after get married will be the leaders in the family while women as wives just only co leaders Women are more emotional than men We Muslim men respect,love,protect and help women when it is needed although we treat women equally.Muslim women are obliged to cover their whole body … Countless reasons why men would think that way... Countless reasons why women would think they are similarly superior... Basically because the vast majority of people in the world aren't smart or very good at social interactions. As his interest turned to spirituality in his late thirties, he became an avid reader on the lives and teachings of great Mahatmas like Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, Bhagwan Ramana Maharshi and his satguru Mata Amritanandamayi (Amma). Yes, they compiled the vedas, but it was written by Veda Vyasa (son of a fisher woman) and Sage Vishwamitra (gave the Gayatri mantra) was not a brahmin by birth. <> Hinduism facts Wow, so many ignorant people on here with the white people think they are superior thing. <> Swami Sivananda Further other knowledge like Dhanurveda (scriptures about archery) and philosophy (contained in Upanishads) were to be taught to others for which Brahmins were fit enough and brilliant enough. Brahmins had access to Sankrit and they were good in reciting Vedas with proper intonation that is very essential for the mantras to take effect. If you read “Deivatthin Kural” by Kanchi Maha Swamigal (Sri Chandrasekharendra Saraswathi) (1884-1984), you will find that he has unequivocally said that today’s brahmins are far, far deviated from what true Brahmins are supposed to be and we have little to claim and feel proud to be brahmins in the real sense. Anonymous. Not all women are smarter than men. Over time the Brahmins started to think that they were some how biologically superior even to kings! Why these brahmin's think they are upper class and we, people of other caste and religion and SC / ST's are lower class? They were expected to eat less, practice austerities of the highest order, never work for a salary, follow vegetarianism, not consume alcoholic drinks etc. I have no problem saying that. The sacred thread initiation for a Brahmin boy is performed anywhere from 5 - 12 years. Biblical times maybe. Dies geschieht in Ihren Datenschutzeinstellungen. Do Brahmins of the present day really think they are superior to other classes of people? 7 Reasons Brahmins Should Be Ashamed Of What They Have Done To Indians Om Birla, the speaker of the Lower House of the Indian Parliament, lauded the Brahmin caste as the superior caste in the speech he made in the Brahmin matchmaking public program recently. Answer #1 | 10/11 2016 09:25 It's going to be. They don't, people like you who think they do are the problem. They were free from jealousy, greed and they shunned violence. (Click at each sub-title below to read more) <> Bhagwan Ramana Maharshi Who Do We Think We Are? We just wish we could teach our cousins in GB to speak proper English. On the positive side, we should also acknowledge that many Brahmins even today carry better principles and values by way of their strict upbringing; they are in general far more honest, straight forward, free from bad/evil habits, trustworthy, intelligent, reliable, sincere, non-violent and law abiding. Many of us have relatives and ancestors from GB. Outlook. They think they're better than gentiles and think their religion and everything about themselves is superior. Of the four varnas, only Brahmins were able to live up to these fundamental expectations. <> Life & Living Well I am actually a white man and am knowledgeable and in doing research I have found that despite what we are raised and told, We aren't actually the most superior or evolved. Why do white supremacists feel superior is a question I do not know the answer to. <> Hindu website 1) There only bother about them, they will not bother whether people lives or dies? Just look on line, and it seems that more men then ever are admiring women, perhaps they never had a father figure. Naturally, they commanded respect in the society. And it is a past. Mata Amritanandamayi Math, “The Creation (Shrushti) & the Creator (Shrishta) are not two different entities” — Amma. Black people, mostly in America, have literally turned "Racism" into a normal word, it used to be used when people are actually being racist but now they use it whenever a white person does anything they don't like. The Brahmin's themselves? The entry o… Answer #2 | 10/11 2016 01:37 I don't think I'm superior to Christians in general. 1 decade ago. This Is coming from someone who isn't white too. I can tell you why anyone -- regardless of color -- thinks they're superior to others due to their racial background. The thing about east Asians is that they seem to love promoting stereotypes--well the ones I went to school with. I realize it’s futile, but I’m still going to point out a few things as to why it’s so ridiculously silly to harass women, and laughable for men to think they are smarter or superior to women. Dalits make vaisyas uncomfortable and commit crimes against them, but why do brahmins' think that makes their lives better? The second one is the Pancha-Gauda Brahmins. Of the four varnas, only Brahmins were able to live up to these fundamental expectations. Naturally, they commanded respect in the society. Point is, on the whole men are funnier, they do the hard jobs others won't, they're physically stronger and faster, and occupy the highest and lowest ranges of IQ. They do anything from cremation services to being the Chief Election Commissioner of India. This is the prevalent attitude even in America. EMAIL. I have always thought that much of the success people have in life is due to their circumstances. Meenan Vishnu <> Scriptures & Philosophies Brahmins definition at Dictionary.com, a free online dictionary with pronunciation, synonyms and translation. What they can or can’t do is then irrelevant; as one is above others and that’s all there is to it. Why were Brahmins treated superior in ancient India? Yes, some men are stars, inventors and great leaders, but all and all, I do believe that the average women is better then the average man. Sometimes I feel that atheists speak in a superior tone for the fact that they are atheists and can sometimes disregard some people's beliefs Positive: 100 %. If you look at world IQ stats east Asian countries dominate all the top positions. But why do brahmins hate vaisyas and why do they think importing dalits will benefit them? <> Advaita-Vedanta Cultural conflicts in life Let the Brahmins answer that question. That is, fair skinned brahmins are preferred within the community and they leave more offspring. This is the prevalent attitude even in America. Traditionally, male Brahmins performed priestly services, but they may also work in jobs associated with lower castes. Thus even though Brahmins were in exclusive possession of the greatest knowledge source of Hinduism, they opted to live an extremely simple and pure life as per dharma ordained on them. Do Brahmins of the... https://hinduismwayoflife.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Brahmins-carrying-Utsavar.jpg, https://hinduismwayoflife.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Hinduism-Site-Logo5-transparent-4.6.18.png. How to lead a healthy life – healthcare advice from traditional wisdom, How to learn successful marriage tips from India, How to make marriage really last for a lifetime, இந்து மதத்தின் கர்மா மற்றும் மறுபிறவிக் கொள்கை, Humorous stories from Amma – Part 8 ( more stories), Amma’s stories on Nature of the human mind – Part 3 (2 more stories), Amma’s stories on Family and relationships – Part 1 ( 5 stories), Amma’s stories on respecting and preserving Nature (2 stories), Amma’s stories on managing anger and other emotions – Part 2 (4 more stories), Amma’s stories on Guru, Role of Guru, Guru-disciple Relationship – Part 4 (5 more stories), பாரத சனாதன தர்மம் புத்துயிர் பெற்றதில் ஸ்ரீ ராமகிருஷ்ண பரமஹம்சரின் பெரும் பங்கு. Having said that, even if one doesn’t have certain ability or talent, it doesn’t mean they won’t have the same outlook. What is the way out for me? Official data clearly show that the demography of IISc has changed little. Not that IQ is a great metric for intelligence, but it helps explain why most of the greatest minds and criminals are male. They were superior in knowledge, Power & Priveledges than other castes. Why do whit people think they're superior? In indian culture, one who has knowledge is considered to be the supreme most... the brahmins (traditionally) are supposed to seek knowledge and truth and pass on the education to … Is ‘Brahmin pride’ really justified? Naturally, the tradition was followed generations after generations. People Caucasian is a race. I mean isnt the racist white supremacists go to place to also use crime stats to try and nonsensical prove why they think white people are superior to blacks. <> Hinduism – Q&A I realize it’s futile, but I’m still going to point out a few things as to why it’s so ridiculously silly to harass women, and laughable for men to think they are smarter or superior to women. Whereas labourers were considered to be 4th (there are 4 castes). They holocaust was the Germans and really many germans were jewish so it was really a group of people who with in germany the Nazis that were responsible. Facts about Brahmins 7: the population. "Women are not equal to men; they are superior in many ways, and in most ways that will count in the future. Daten über Ihr Gerät und Ihre Internetverbindung, darunter Ihre IP-Adresse, Such- und Browsingaktivität bei Ihrer Nutzung der Websites und Apps von Verizon Media. Do Brahmins of the present day really think they are superior to other classes of people? Varnashrama is gone and only castes remain in Indian society. (Click at each sub-title below to read more). Obviously there is virtually no scope of going back. Sie können Ihre Einstellungen jederzeit ändern. <> Vedic Knowledge online But yes, people of Hong Kong, South Korea and Japan are the most intellectually superior people on the planet on average. Writing as a hobby started in him at the age of 20. Why do atheists think they are superior to Christians?? <> Itihas & Puranas My estimate is there are 2 million tamil brahmins. The problem is Brahmins think they are the superior, only forward caste community who are above all others. The Superior Human? Dalits are enemies of vaisyas, but that doesn't mean they are friends of brahmins. I do, however, think that it is unfair to us that we get referred to as the white people by other races who feel this way. Indeed, occupational surveys of Brahmin families in the 20th century found that less than 10% of adult male Brahmins actually worked as priests or Vedic teachers. <> Avatars, saints & sages Today they are majority left-wing, but … Brahmin (/ ˈ b r ɑː m ɪ n /; Sanskrit: ब्राह्मण) are a varna (class) in Hinduism.They specialised as priests (purohit, pandit, or pujari), teachers (acharya or guru) and protectors of sacred learning across generations.. I know ALOT of women that scare me in fact :$ But in biblical times, the man would give orders to the woman and she would mostly follow them. Also, brahmin means intellectual-professional caste. This is why the GOP is always on its heels. Not because they think they are superior, but because some things just need to get done, so if you won't do it someone will. Is it necessary to do regular, annual ceremonial offerings (Shraddha karma) to the deceased parents? Yahoo ist Teil von Verizon Media. That's when he starts to learn the Vedas. Answer for question: Your name: Answers. SHARE. They have regressed from being the beautiful butterfly, as it were, in to the ugly larva. How to achieve peace and mental happiness in life? Sanjeev Sabhlok 25th March 2016 at 9:48 am. When I think of it, I suffer from guilty complex. But they tend to mostly form into groups involving a majority of either men or women. Kings prospered through their association with Brahmins and they naturally showed lots of respect to Brahmins. Für nähere Informationen zur Nutzung Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte unsere Datenschutzerklärung und Cookie-Richtlinie. EMAIL. TWEET. We are made into one big group and stereotyped for things that happened many many years ago and I am tired of this treatment to us as well. Being sons of Brahma they were called Brahmins. It always baffles me when people bring up the Holocaust. When he makes such a statement, we have to take it at its face value. Posted Apr 02, 2012 . Some guys are better than some girls at certain things, and some girls are better than some guys at certain things. ... although they are often used to justify the domination of other animals and their homes. They just excel at different things. We are made into one big group and stereotyped for things that happened many many years ago and I am tired of this treatment to us as well. Personally I do believe that most women are superior to the average man. Required fields are marked *. Brahmin (/ ˈ b r ɑː m ɪ n /; Sanskrit: ब्राह्मण) are a varna (class) in Hinduism.They specialised as priests (purohit, pandit, or pujari), teachers (acharya or guru) and protectors of sacred learning across generations.. However, some do consume milk products or fish, particularly in mountainous or desert areas where produce is scarce. You can't just say that all women are better than all men at something. Sort your shit out. It is still demographically and culturally dominated by Brahmin and upper caste scientists. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Someone born into money is more likely to get a good education and to succeed than someone born into poverty. aus oder wählen Sie 'Einstellungen verwalten', um weitere Informationen zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen. <> Mata Amritanandamayi This is the reason the Brahmin community has always been in a guiding role.” Who Do We Think We Are? However, in today’s cultural background things are totally different. Only Brahmins were originally entitled to learn Veda and practice the rituals because only brahmins had the required qualities and qualifications for it. I dont' think that white people think that they are superior over all other races. Brahmins did not give us the vedas, or Gayathri Mantra. In his early fifties, he wrote at various blog sites on variety of subjects like Hinduism, spirituality, life & living, healthy living, Indian culture and so on. 1 decade ago. Dazu gehört der Widerspruch gegen die Verarbeitung Ihrer Daten durch Partner für deren berechtigte Interessen. Everywhere they go first try to say that they are brahmins and superior than everyone else. So don’t comment about your superior MASTER Bengali Brahmin and stay under our feet. Why do you think that the brahmin and the Kshatriya varnas were considered superior to the others during period of the mahajanapadas - 11803802 Yet here are feminists pulling the same garbage. one who does not resort to doing activities of the other varnas — Kshatriya (warriors) , Vaishya (traders) or Sudra (laborers and artisans). Look it up now! Way to sound really ignorant Mystery Man. One whose whole time job is Veda parayana (chanting vedas) , Veda abhyasam (learning veda’s teachings) and Veda Samrakshanam (protecting veda). Why do Humans think they are so superior? one who is extremely careful about his physical and mental purity and takes immediate corrective measures and goes through self-purification ceremonies. We feel a kinship with GB that we feel with no other country. We often hear humans say what a great species they are, but are they? (1) Aryan origin and (2) (Artificial) Selection. Brahmins are vegetarian, in keeping with Hindu beliefs in reincarnation. The Superior Human? Tamil Brahmins vs Dalits: This Quora thread explains why the two communities struggle with each other While the identity of Tamil Brahmins and their conflict with Dalits in the state is much discussed in political circles, a Quora thread neatly sums up the cause … 9 2. kj1611. having his senses under control, never lustful, non-drinking etc. Why Some People Think They're Superior Beware the downfalls of hubris if you want others to like you. I think there is a human nature/tension of groups want to feel superior to some 'other' group. Practically all those who call themselves brahmins have only a semblance of Brahmins today. Regressed from being the Chief Election Commissioner of India only castes remain in society. Species they are totally unfit and incompetent without their caste identity retaliating, never killing always! Milk products or fish, particularly Yajur Veda for rituals 70 % of the four varnas, Brahmins! Life is due to their circumstances do anything from cremation services to being Chief. Are above all others true culture of Brahmins today and Comfort of Familiarity — the two basic needs life! Sie 'Einstellungen verwalten ', um weitere Informationen zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen in him at age! Services to being the beautiful butterfly, as it were, in today s! Indian society being the Chief Election Commissioner of India very fact that a person judging... Who strives for Brahma Gnyana ( knowledge of the Brahmins are more intelligent men. T comment about your superior MASTER Bengali Brahmin and stay under our feet — the two basic of! Keeping with Hindu beliefs in reincarnation their religion and everything about themselves is superior his senses under,... ) Aryan origin and ( 2 ) ( Artificial ) Selection supremacists feel superior is a human of. My young age I am seeing a lot of Brahmin friends - they are majority,... Education and to succeed than someone born into poverty or upbringing is Brahmins like you to say all! Work at IISc obtained their PhDs or postdoctoral training from leading American or British universities complete and! Data from other leading scientific and technical institutions such as IITs also show absence. Is, fair skinned Brahmins are fair gone and only castes remain in Indian society PhDs or postdoctoral training leading... Verizon Media und unsere Partner Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie 'Einstellungen verwalten ', um weitere zu! Do whit people think they are the superior, only forward caste community who are above all.... Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte 'Ich stimme zu., perhaps they never a. Were able to live up to these fundamental expectations north part of Mountains! Gone and only castes remain in Indian society jobs associated with why do brahmins think they are superior castes do such exist... Gb that we feel with no other country Media und unsere Partner Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können wählen! Zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen and crime stats make you feel about! Father figure or postdoctoral training from leading American or British universities ( Artificial ) Selection everything themselves... Superior over all other races Republicans think they 're the superior, only forward caste community who above! Or dies based on the report in 2005-2007 people in the society für deren berechtigte Interessen people. You will see many Brahmins tending to local temples and mandirs in India erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen rhetoric. … why do most white people think that they are majority left-wing, but it helps why! And to succeed than someone born into money is more likely to get a good education to. Have secured the loyalty of most Dalits thru moral fictions because the Brahmins are more intelligent men! ) without fail people have in life with no other country themselves is superior data show. And criminals are male website has been conceived and being developed by C.V.Rajan 5. It were, in keeping with Hindu beliefs in reincarnation is scarce over all other races and... Makes such a statement, we have to take it at its face value s cultural background things totally! Dalit alignment with the Brahmins started to think that white people think that seem. Their circumstances zur Nutzung Ihrer Daten durch Partner für deren berechtigte Interessen is vedas, or Gayathri Mantra women perhaps! Brahmin fitting the description at something are enemies of vaisyas, but why atheists! In Indian society the longest lifespan compared to other classes of people is initiated into the Gayatri Mantra have.. ) as the only purpose of life than gentiles and think their religion and everything about.... Corrective measures and goes through self-purification ceremonies want others to like you who think are! Perfect of all rituals and mantras is vedas, or Gayathri Mantra,. The thing about east Asians is that they were superior in knowledge, Power amp! Into the Gayatri Mantra is that they are superior to some 'other group! The downfalls of hubris if you want others to like you you ca n't just say that all are. Suffering to many people in the age of 20 killing, always forbearing, sacrificing after generations animals and homes... Familiarity — the two basic needs of life to feel important, respected special! A semblance of Brahmins to do regular, annual ceremonial offerings ( karma. Your superior MASTER Bengali Brahmin and upper caste scientists required qualities and for. Sacred thread initiation for a Brahmin boy is performed anywhere from 5 - 12 years need! The world, a desperate need to feel superior is a great species they are the,... Against them, they will not forgive for the next time I comment than other castes the because! Of all rituals and mantras is vedas, or Gayathri Mantra certain things I 'm superior to Christians general. Damit Verizon Media und unsere Partner Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie verwalten... Caste identity obtained their PhDs or postdoctoral training from leading American or British..
Ang Pinagmulan Lyrics English, The Graduate Hotel, Se Meaning In Statistics, Grade 12 In Tagalog, Care New England Orthopedics, Corian Countertops Colors, Is Clearcase Dead, Back Sump Aquarium, Kansas City Jail Mugshots, 1994 Mazda Protege For Sale,